A simple formula that few traders utilize
Most traders will blurt out the answer “Flat!”, and that is wrong. The correct answer is you will lose money, at the rate of 0.5% every minute! That is because for a geometric random walk, the average compounded rate of return is not the short-term (or one-period) return m (1% here), but is m – s2/2, where s (also 1% here) is the standard deviation of the short-term return. This is consistent with the fact that the geometric mean of a set of numbers is always smaller than the arithmetic mean (unless the numbers are identical, in which case the two means are the same). When we assume, as I did, that the arithmetic mean of the returns is zero, the geometric mean, which gives the average compounded rate of return, must be negative.
This quantity m – s2/2 holds the key to selecting a maximum growth strategy. In a previous article (“How much leverage should you use?”), I described a scheme to maximize the long-run growth rate of a given investment strategy (i.e., a strategy with a fixed m and s) by leveraging. However, often we are faced with a choice of different strategies with different expected returns and risk. How do we choose between them? Many traders think that we should pick the one with the highest Sharpe ratio. This is reasonable if a trader fix each of his or her bet to have a constant size. But if you are a trader interested in maximizing long-run wealth (like the Kelly investor I mentioned in the previous article), the bet size should always be proportional to the compounded return. Maximizing Sharpe ratio does not guarantee maximal growth for multi-period returns. Maximizing m – s2/2 does.
Miller, Stephen J. The Arithmetic and Geometric Mean Inequality. ArithMeanGeoMean.pdf
Sharpe, William. Multi-period Returns. http://www.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/mia/rr/mia_rr3.htm
Poundstone, William. (2005). Fortune’s Formula. New York: Hill and Wang.
5 comments:
EC-
In m – s2/2, does m always mean rate of return and s2/2 always mean standard deviation in the short run?
Sorry for so many Qs, I'm quite new to quantitative trading. thanks!
Yes, m is the short run mean return, s is the short run mean s.d. See John Hull's book on options also.
Regarding: "The correct answer is you will lose money, at the rate of 0.5% every minute!"
I think it is worth mentioning that the expected profit from that investment is 0.
For example, for a two minute run, there are four equally likely scenarios: Lose-Lose, Lose-Win, Win-Lose, Win-Win. The respective returns from a 1 unit investment would be 0.9801, 0.9999, 0.9999 and 1.0201, which average 1 - even if most outcomes are losses.
...Ernie, I think you've made a mistake stating expected .5% per minute loss.
Let's redo the math: your expected return per time step is 0.5*log(1.01)+0.5*log(0.99), which is -5.0003e-005 or rather 0.005% . You are 1e3 off.
Hi sjev,
You are right. It was also pointed out by various readers before and I posted a correction some time ago here: http://epchan.blogspot.com/2006/11/correction-maximizing-compounded-rate.html
Ernie
Post a Comment